How to Quiet Your Inner Critic - Therapy for Self-Doubt & Shame
- Mae Winters
- 7 days ago
- 4 min read
The Voice That Never Seems to Take a Day Off
The harsh inner critic rarely announces itself.
It slips in mid-thought—half a sentence you didn’t finish, a feeling you couldn’t quite name—and suddenly your mind is reviewing everything you did wrong today.
That wasn’t very smart.
Everyone else seems to manage this better.
Why do you always do this?
The harsh inner critic doesn’t whisper—it narrates. It reviews your mistakes, predicts your failures, and keeps a running score of everything you should have done differently. And the most unsettling part? It sounds believable. Familiar. Like it knows you better than anyone else.
Very few people walk into therapy and say, “I hate myself.”
What I hear instead are quieter truths:
“I’m too hard on myself”
“My mind never slows down”
“No matter how much I do, it never feels like enough.”
If you live with self-doubt or shame, chances are your inner critic is working overtime—and calling it “motivation.”
You’re not imagining it. And you’re not alone.
Let Me Tell You Something Most People Miss
Your inner critic did not appear because you’re weak.
It appeared because, at some point, being hard on yourself felt safer than being disappointed, rejected, or hurt again.
That realization alone changes everything.
A Story I Hear All the Time
A client once said to me, “If I talked to anyone else the way I talk to myself, I wouldn’t have a single relationship left.”
We sat with that for a moment.
Because what they were describing wasn’t a personality flaw—it was a relationship pattern. One they’d learned early, practiced often, and never questioned.
Their inner critic had become their internal authority.
The loudest voice in the room.
The one that decided whether they were worthy of rest, joy, or self-respect.
And here’s the cliffhanger most people don’t expect:
The inner critic isn’t your enemy. But it is outdated.
Why the Inner Critic Exists (Even When It Hurts)
From a neuroscience perspective, your brain’s primary job is survival—not happiness, not confidence, not peace.
Your inner critic developed as a protective strategy. If it could point out flaws early, maybe you’d avoid rejection. If it kept you striving, maybe you’d stay accepted. If it shamed you first, maybe others wouldn’t get the chance.
In Buddhist psychology, this is sometimes described as the protective mind—a part of us that believes control equals safety.
The problem is that the inner critic doesn’t update itself automatically.
It keeps using the same old methods long after the threat is gone.
So instead of helping you grow, it keeps you stuck in:
Chronic self-doubt
Persistent shame
Overthinking and paralysis
Emotional burnout disguised as “high standards”
This is why so many intelligent, capable, successful people feel secretly exhausted inside.
Here’s Why Your Mental Health Isn’t Improving (And How to Fix It)
Most people try to quiet their inner critic by fighting it.
They argue with it.
They shame themselves for being negative.
They try to drown it out with positivity.
That usually backfires.
Because the inner critic isn’t logical—it’s relational.
You don’t silence it by overpowering it.
You soften it by changing how you relate to it.
Research on self-compassion shows something counterintuitive: People who treat themselves with kindness are more resilient, more accountable, and more emotionally regulated—not less.
Self-compassion isn’t letting yourself off the hook.
It’s creating an internal environment where change is actually possible.
The Small Shift That Makes All the Difference
Instead of asking, “How do I get rid of this voice?”
Try asking, “What is this voice trying to protect me from?”
That question alone often takes the edge off.
Because beneath harsh self-talk is usually fear:
Fear of being unlovable
Fear of being exposed
Fear of failing again
Fear of not being enough
When we slow down and listen—not obey, not argue, just notice—the inner critic doesn’t need to scream as loudly.
This is where therapy becomes transformative.
What Inner Critic Therapy Actually Looks Like
Quieting the inner critic isn’t about becoming endlessly positive or “high vibe.”
It’s about building a new internal relationship.
In our work together, we don’t shame the critic or try to eliminate it. We get curious. We track patterns. We separate your identity from your inner commentary.
We explore:
Where the critic learned its language
What situations activate it most
How shame and self-doubt show up in your relationships
How to respond without collapsing or overcompensating
We integrate neuroscience, attachment work, mindfulness, and—yes—Buddhist principles that emphasize awareness over judgment.
And slowly, something shifts.
The critic may still show up—but it no longer runs the show.
Most People Miss This…
The goal isn’t to never have self-critical thoughts.
The goal is to stop believing everything your mind says about you.
That’s freedom.
That’s healing.
And it’s absolutely learnable.
A Gentle Reality Check
If you’ve tried journaling, affirmations, self-help books, and podcasts—and still feel stuck—it’s not because you’re doing it wrong.
It’s because the inner critic doesn’t heal in isolation.
It heals in relationship.
That’s what therapy offers.
A Clear Next Step (No Guesswork)
If you’re tired of living with constant self-doubt…
If shame has been quietly shaping your choices…
If you want therapy that feels real, relational, and deeply human…
I would love to work with you.
Mae Winters, LPC
Licensed in Virginia, Maine, Connecticut, and Vermont
I’m currently accepting new clients.
This can be the beginning of a quieter mind, a steadier nervous system, and a kinder relationship with yourself—without losing your strength, depth, or drive.
Comments